Case study: White Hat Media by Rachelle Money, 11 June 2008

Search Engine Optimization is never black or white, or is it? We talk to White Hat Media's Romain Romagnan about black hat and white hat SEO, and on how to avoid rogue traders.
Key points
- A white hat SEO company will not guarantee you will come top for specific keywords.
- Black hat SEO companies will only achieve short term success by concentrating on search engines.
For those not in the know, the difference between wearing a black hat and white hat in SEO terms goes well beyond color or making a fashion statement - it reveals the whole ethical foundation upon which a company stands.
Beware those in black hats: they may look like magicians, but they can trick anyone with a hocus pocus of promises they can’t keep - which could make your dreams of good search engine rankings vanish into thin air. Thankfully there are SEO companies who avoid all risk of confusion - like White Hat Media.
The company, based in East Sussex, England was set up in 2003 as a web development agency by Kevin Elliot and Jeremy Spiller, who between them have more than 20 years experience in IT and New Media. Since then the company has grown arms, legs and a head to encompass a range of new media tools such as e-marketing and Pay Per Click, as well as helping companies set up online shops and, the golden jewel in their crown, SEO services.
To find out more, [Wordtracker] spoke to Romain Romagnan, a search consultant who has been with White Hat Media for a year.
“Most people don’t realize what ‘white hat’ means in our name but it’s because we are a white hat SEO company. White hat uses all the right techniques to get your site properly geared up to reach high on Google for key phrases. Black hat techniques will hide content from the reader. White hat SEO is just thinking about the reader and the search engine, whereas black hat SEO is thinking about the search engine first.”
With many SEOs out there luring customers with impressive promises, Romagnan said people should be wary.
“A company doing white hat SEO will not guarantee that you will come top for keywords. No SEO company can guarantee that because you don’t know the competition, or how things may change in your industry. So make sure they are not making big promises, because it’s more than likely they can’t keep them.”
So when a client comes to White Hat Media looking to take advantage of their SEO expertise what are the first steps?
Romagnan said: “We tend to have a look at the website and then ask for about 12 keywords they wish to target or which they want to come top. “I think what surprises people most about keyword research is that sometimes when you add an ‘s’ to a word (to make it plural) it can have a big effect on the keyword rankings. Or sometimes little things like having two keywords inverted can make a difference too, these are the kinds of things people don’t realize when they do keyword research.”
It’s clear from White Hat Media’s homepage that they are proud of the SEO services they provide. They have developed a great tool for companies to use to test how ‘search engine friendly’ their website is. As a prospective client you are taken to a list of SEO tools such as Alexa Rank where you can track the amount of traffic coming through your site and compare that to your competitors'. White Hat Media also offers a range of other tools in this section including keyword suggestions, keyword position and density, a back-link checker and a tool to discover your site’s link popularity. As you begin to learn about the ways in which people are searching for your site, and how your site is interpreted by the search engines, you can use these valuable tools to set about optimizing your site. To gauge how effective your SEO work has been you can revisit Alexa Rank and see for yourself how much additional traffic you have achieved and whether you have eclipsed your competitors.
Over recent years SEO has crept into the foundations of online marketing, as Romagnan explains.
“We do SEO for people when they want email marketing and need to issue newsletters. We do it mainly for calls to action and to get the right keywords to appeal to the customer and give a clear message to the customers as quickly as possible.
“I think most people forget that creating a call to action on their site is very important - sometimes it seems like they forget about it.” White Hat Media show their customers how to capture email addresses on their website, and how to create strong copy and good quality templates for email marketing campaigns.
On their blog, White Hat Media makes it clear that customers should be thinking about writing good copy for their website because, “Google loves content.” The blog goes on to suggest that people should “stop writing rubbish for your website” and think creatively about what is relevant.
White Hat Media's Papers and Articles section is a triumph. In the pull-down menus at the top, each tab links you to a page where they give general information about strategic planning, corporate research, site engineering, link building etc. In most cases they then provide a link to their Papers and Articles section for a more detailed look at the topic. All the sections are regularly updated and provide interesting tips and ideas on how to improve your site.
One interesting article posted just a few weeks ago by White Hat Media pointed towards a growing trend in the area of social media. This will come as no surprise to many. Blogs and the like were once mainly used by the general public - they were an outlet for musing, exchanging ideas and making connections. Now however, the rise of the corporate blog for networking and promotion has broadened the blogging population. And the same is happening in social media outlets like Facebook, MySpace and Bebo.
In the White Hat Media article posted on November 28 2007 it says: “It is estimated that by 2010, 70% of internet content will be user-generated, and big brands are keen to jump on the Web 2.0, social media bandwagon. Social Media Optimization (SMO) will be the future of SEO, where rankings are based less upon the manipulation of code and more about old fashioned PR,” like word-of-mouth.
Romagnan says this is something White Hat Media have been concentrating on in the last three months, with great results. They are now enticing their clients to make the best of social media outlets and create their own MySpace pages or Bebo sites to promote their products within these ready-made online communities.
“I find it a great tool to use because you can get inbound links from posts to blogs and other sites like Facebook, or any of those social media links. It should be used more by SEO companies“, declares Romagnan.
“Everything including video and podcasting can be very useful for companies to promote themselves through. I don’t think too many people are doing this right now, but I think we will start to see more companies on Facebook and MySpace, using these sites as a tool to market themselves online“, he added.
White Hat Media suggests using other forms of SMO to generate publicity - these include adding RSS feeds, a ‘Digg This’ button and incorporating third party community functionalities such as Flickr photo slides and galleries, or YouTube videos.
White Hat Media’s Top SEO tips
Identify Correct Keywords. Your site should include keywords that your prospective clients key into the major search engines.
Optimize Your Page Titles
One of the most vital SEO techniques is to position your keywords within the Title description for each page. This will assist your search engine rankings and help users to identify the content of the page when they bookmark it.
Build Internal Links
An often mistaken assumption is that every visitor will start at your homepage. Most will, but it's important to check that each page on your site is linked to the others.
Develop Inbound Links
You should seek inbound links from other relevant websites. Linking from text placed in the body of other websites is very valuable, particularly if it includes your keywords. Be very selective when choosing link partners.
Meta Tags
Some SEO professionals suggest that using tags is the best way to optimize your web page by letting the search engine spiders know which are the most important words.
To read the full top 10 tips visit White Hat Media - Papers and Articles
For more on SEO have a look at our SEO strategy page.
About Rachelle Money
Rachelle Money is a freelance journalist based in Scotland, UK. She graduated from the Scottish School of Journalism in 2005 where she was awarded an internship with two national publications - The Sunday Herald newspaper and The Big Issue magazine. Rachelle has been working with Wordtracker since August 2007 and is a regular contributor to the newsletter.








13 comments
Fantastic informative article. It has taught me more than all the money I've wasted with marketing companies-yes I am one of those idiots who ha been taken in with fantastic promises. I'm about to re-write my site and add much more content. Hopefully I can get my site back on track. I'm trying to change people's perceptions about wearing a hairpiece-not that you would realise this looking at my site at the moment, but watch this space and thank you once again for your great writing.
It's a balancing act of using social media sites for business and not getting banned (at least what I have come across so far). Hopefully soon I will grasp the total benefits of social media promotions. Great post - thanks.
the difference between white and black hat companies are pretty obvious... i which there was more info on what is sometimes referred to as gray hats? Is there a blur between the lines?
Great post! Thanks.
Hi thanks for the interesting article very informative to say the least.
Interesting.
A representative of a "white hat" company only talks about keywords, links, etc, but not about conversions, people and ROI.
Even if his tactics are whitehat, it doesn't mean that he puts humans on the first place.
If you take people into account, you forget about links: you start building conversations, communities, value and such. Sheesh. Maybe you need to find a more value-oriented marketer (yes, SEO is marketing mostly nowadays), like Ammon Johns from FreshEgg, West Sussex, Worthing?
I believe that someone claiming to use "white hat" tactics put human on the 1st place most of the time! On top of that i'd say how about talking about keyword research on a site that provide a keyword tool! Ohh...but it's kind of already in this case study...
Interesting article. I liked the top ten tips as it a good starting point for clients to get an idea of Search Marketing. Its interesting that the person profiled in the article likens Social Media to old fashioned PR, but then goes on to suggest that it is a tool to help market themselves online. Old fashion PR was more about the customer, it was focused on customer service and the trade off was good word of mouth. Using Social Media as a 'tool' to build links is using the medium for the wrong reasons, its just focusing on 'whats in it for me' rather than giving something back. Social Media is a great way to offer your services but it has to be about the relationship and not the sale, otherwise blatant abuse of social media for our marketing benefits will destroy the medium.
Very nice article. I think many people are not sure about the difference between black and white hat. It is very important to know the difference if you want your site to be around for the long term.
I'm new to this whole SEO thing. Thank you for taking the time to write these informative articles...I'm listening!
Write more keyword rich content- use all the available tags (meta, title, H1 to H3's) not exactly news, just right on the money.
I took a look at their site and tried the tools, really good!!
HAHA white hat media are the biggest load of unscupulous SEO people we have ever met! Clients come to us all the time who have been fleeced by White Hat. Dont believe the hype!